You Are a Whirlpool · Letter 11

fol. 18
  1. The five rules
  2. I
  3. II
  4. III
  5. IV
  6. V
Letter 11 · Rule II · Map

Whose Voice Is in Your Head

Many of your beliefs were handed to you by other people before you could check them; a belief becomes yours when you’ve tested it yourself.

A letter from Justin Hartfield. About 4 minutes.

One day you’ll be tired, and someone will do something small but annoying, and a sentence will come out of your mouth that will be eerily familiar. You’ll stop and wonder for a half second where that came from. But then you’ll suddenly know where. You heard it a hundred times growing up, because those sentences were mine. I hope a few of them are good ones. But I’m sure some of them I inherited from my own parents and I helplessly passed the meme along to you guys.

That’s rule two, the map, showing you who drew it. You drew very little of your map yourself. Most of it was handed to you before you could check it. The people who raised you drew some. So did teachers, coaches, friends, the where you grew up in, the iPads game ads you watched and the Netflix series you binged. In these letters I call that your Roots: the part of you that’s older than you. Your Roots feed you whether or not you ever look at them.

None of that is bad. Most of what you were handed kept you alive. Look both ways. Don’t touch the stove. Say thank you. If you had to test every one of those yourself, you’d be in trouble by lunch. The only problem is that a borrowed belief (from dear ol’ dad or anybody else) and a tested one feel exactly the same from inside your own mind. Both sound like your truth. Both are in your own voice.

Three things follow from this.

First, ask whose voice it is. A belief you were handed usually comes with a face. Say it slowly, out loud: “Chill out.” “Eat your food, please.” “Don’t worry about it.” Then listen for who’s saying it. Sometimes it will be Mom or Dad. Sometimes it’s a coach, a friend from long ago, or an ad you saw a thousand times. Sometimes you can’t hear anyone at all, and those may be the ones you built yourself. Knowing whose voice it is doesn’t make it wrong. It only tells you that you should probably check it for accuracy.

Second, test it. That’s rule five: the world gets the last word. A belief becomes yours when you’ve seen it work in your own life. Many old rules were right for the age you were when you got them. “Don’t talk to strangers” kept you safe at six. At thirty, almost every job, friend and partner you’ll ever have starts out as a stranger. The rule wasn’t wrong, you just grew past it. So when you find a borrowed voice, don’t argue with it in your head. Instead, in some small, safe way, and see what the world says. If the voice was right, keep it, and now it’s yours. If it wasn’t, thank it and let it go.

Third, choose the next voices. Whatever you feed, grows. That’s rule three. The voices in your head at whatever age you’re reading this are moving in now, from whoever you spend your days listening to. That means the people you keep close, the things you read, and the things you scroll past at night. You can’t clear your head of voices, and you wouldn’t want to. But from here on, you get a say in whose get to stay.

That goes for me too. These letters are a voice in your head now. Don’t keep any of it on my say-so. Test it like the rest. Trust me I’ve tested almost everything and so far I only found the five rules you have on this website.

A young woman looks into a hand mirror while a crowd of people around her point and lean in to whisper
A young woman looks into a hand mirror while a crowd of people around her point and lean in to whisper

Try this tonight.

Write down ten things you believe about how life works. Short lines, about money, work, people, and yourself. Next to each one, write whose voice you hear when you read it. If you honestly can’t hear anyone, write “mine.” Then put a check mark next to the ones you’ve seen work in your own life. Don’t cross anything out. The lines with a name and no check mark are your list. Pick one, and find a small, safe way to test it before the week is over.

One line to remember

Every belief came from somewhere. Keep the ones that pass your own test.

The earlier essay this letter grew from